Thirty-six years and three months ago today, a young Navy Lieutenant testified before congress about the war he had just been in and that was still ongoing (transcript). It took another four years for the Vietnam War to come to a conclusion, at least where US involvement was concerned. Many soldiers paid with their lives after the war was already lost and should have been ended.
Today we find ourselves at the same crossroads yet again. We are entangled in a conflict that our government lied us into, and that has evolved beyond our ability to work out militarily.
Four years after Mr. Bush has declared Mission Accomplished, the mission has failed.
Four years after he declared the war as won, it is lost.
Four years after he declared victory over Saddam Hussein and Iraq liberated, the country is being liberated of its citizens, and invaded by a parasitic enemy much less visible than the former dictator, but no less dangerous.
Four years after, and our troops have not come home, and their deaths have multiplied.
When is it time to admit the cause is lost? How many more men and women must die before we realize that we can, and do, lose wars; that sometimes, what is broken can't be fixed, even if we broke it?
Admitting defeat is not a failure. Not admitting it, and slogging on blindly in the face of obvious futility - that is failure. Allowing more deaths by claiming those that have come before would have been senseless otherwise - that is failure.
It takes strength and humility to say; 'I was wrong, and I cannot undo what I did.' That realization alone is the first step to making it right again. We, the people, have been able to say this for a while now.
We have lost. Let us bring our troops home. It is over.
When will our leaders follow?


Comments (3)
Posted by Noisy Democrat | July 22, 2007 3:40 PM
This is an intense and powerful video, and beautifully put together. Thank you for sharing it with us.
Posted by GV | July 22, 2007 10:50 PM
Incredible video, Kerstin. Isn't sad that we didn't learn the lessons of Vietnam? How frustrating and how terribly sad it is to have to re-live the same awful nightmare. How horrible to keep sending our kids to fight and die for old men's choices.
Where's the diplomacy? I remember Carter and Clinton making an effort, but now I don't see any at all. There's no way to win the peace without it. What we need is to get these people to the negotiating table and bring our kids home.
Posted by dwahzon | July 23, 2007 10:15 AM
Kerstin... how powerful. Thank you.